Insights into Anatomical Basis Prescribing Ventilation- Perfusion Distribution in Lung Periphery

Review Article

Austin J Pulm Respir Med 2019; 6(1): 1060.

Insights into Anatomical Basis Prescribing Ventilation- Perfusion Distribution in Lung Periphery

Kazuhiro Yamaguchi*1, Takao Tsuji1, Kazutetsu Aoshiba2, Hiroyuki Nakamura2 and Shinji Abe1

¹Department of Respiratory Medicine, Tokyo Medical University, Japan

²Department of Respiratory Medicine, Tokyo Medical University Ibaraki Medical Center, Japan

*Corresponding author: Kazuhiro Yamaguchi, Department of Respiratory Medicine, Tokyo Medical University, 6-7-1 Nishi-Shinjuku, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo 160-0023, Japan

Received: May 02, 2019; Accepted: June 14, 2019; Published: June 21, 2019

Abstract

Some crucial problems regarding structural (anatomical) basis on functional parameters describing gas exchange in lung periphery have remained unsolved. Although many definitions for anatomical gas exchange unit (i.e., acinus) have been proposed, there are no authentic study for certifying that anatomicallydefined acinus indeed acts as functional gas exchange unit, as well. Among different acini reported so far, we selected acinus of Haefeli-Bleuer (HB acinus) as the most reliable organization. This is simply because microstructures of HB acinus were precisely examined by aid of scanning electron microscopy in addition to light microscopy. Therefore, we first coped with the issue of whether anatomically-defined HB acinus would meet the definition of functional gas exchange unit, i.e., the gas concentration is constant in any region of this organization. We were confronted with an interesting phenomenon that spatial PO2 gradient exists along the axial direction of HB acinus over inspiration, but it almost disappears over expiration, leading to the conclusion that anatomicallydefined HB acinus indeed acts as functional gas exchange unit on expiration but not on inspiration. This fact certainly indicates that functional gas exchange parameters measured on expiration, such as VA/Q heterogeneity investigated from Multiple Inert Gas Elimination Technique (MIGET), can be considered to reflect microstructural abnormalities at the level of HB acinus. Subsequently, we tried to validate the issue of whether VA/Q heterogeneities estimated from MIGET would well explain the structural abnormalities in patients with pathologicallyand/ or radiologically-confirmed lung diseases.

Keywords: Acinus; Anatomical gas exchange unit; Functional gas exchange unit; VA/Q heterogeneity; Multiple inert gas elimination technique

Abbreviations

VA: Alveolar or Effective Ventilation, or Alveolar Volume; Q: Pulmonary Capillary Perfusion; VA/Q: Ventilation-Perfusion Ratio; MIGET: Multiple Inert Gas Elimination Technique; acinus of HB: acinus of Haefeli-Bleuer and Weibel; TB: Terminal Bronchiole; TrB: Transitional Bronchiole; RB: Respiratory Bronchiole; AD: Alveolar Duct; AS: Alveolar Sac; Z: Generation of Airway From Trachea; Z’: Generation of Acinar Airway From Transitional Bronchiole; PFT: Pulmonary Function Test; VC: Vital Capacity; FVC: Forced Vital Capacity; FEV1: Forced Expiratory Volume During One Second; ATI: Air Trapping Index defined as 100.(VC-FVC)/VC; PEF: Peak Expiratory Flow Rate; FEF50: Forced Expiratory Flow Rate at 50% of FVC; TLC: Total Lung Capacity; FRC: Functional Residual Capacity; RV: Residual Volume; PaO2: PO2 in Arterial Blood; AaDO2: Alveolar-Arterial PO2 Difference; PaCO2: PCO2 in Arterial Blood; DLCO: Pulmonary Diffusing Capacity For Carbon Monoxide (CO); KCO: Krogh Factor for CO defined as DLCO/VA, where VA denotes alveolar volume; Hb: Hemoglobin; Pe: Peclet number; d: diameter of airway tube; u: mean convective flow velocity; D: Binary Diffusion Coefficient of Gas; x: axical distance from terminal alveolar sacs; t: time; C: Concentration of Gas; MBNW: Multi-Breath N2 Washout; DCDI: Diffusion-Convection-Dependent Inhomogeneity; P: Partial Pressure of Gas; PA: Partial Pressure of Gas in Alveolar Gas Phase; PC: Partial Pressure of Gas in Pulmonary Capillary; PV: Partial Pressure of Gas in Mixed Venous Blood; E: Excretion of Gas (PA/ PV); R: Retention of Gas (PC/PV); λ: Blood-Gas Partition Coefficient; SF6: Sulfur Hexafluoride; L: Objective Variable Minimized with Respect to Fractional Perfusion; qj: fractional perfusion; vj: fractional ventilation; Ri: Measured Arterial Gas Concentration Divided by its Mixed Venous Concentration; Wi: Coefficient For Weight of Each Gas; μ: Lagrange Multiplier; φj: Compartmental Weight of each VA/Q Unit; S: Smoothing Term; VD/VT: Dead Space Ventilation; QS/ QT: Right-to-Left Shunt; MRI: Magnetic Resonance Imaging; ASL: Arterial Spin Labeling; HPV: Hypoxic Pulmonary Vasoconstriction; COPD: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease; IP: Interstitial Pneumonia; ARDS: Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome; PE: Pulmonary Embolism; BO: Bronchiolitis Obliterans; PPFE: Pleuroparenchymal Fibroelastosis; HSCT: Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation; HPS: Hepatopulmonary Syndrome; IVL: Intravascular Lymphomatosis; PVOD: Pulmonary Veno-Occlusive Disease; PCH: Pulmonary Capillary Hemangiomatosis; LCH: Langerhans Cell Histiocytosis; LAM: Lymphangioleiomyomatosis; ANCA: Anti-Neutrophil Cytoplasmic Antibodies; PAP: Pulmonary Alveolar Proteinosis; DOE: Dyspnea on Exertion; CT: Computed Tomography; GGO: Ground Glass Opacity; VATS: Video-Assisted Thoracoscopy; 99mTc-MAA: Perfusion Scan using 99mTechnetium (Tc) Labeled Macro-Agglutinated Albumin (MAA); 81mKr: 81mKripton; NO: Nitric Oxide; FeNO: Fractional Concentration of Exhaled NO

Introduction

Among the functional parameters that estimate gas exchange dynamics in the lung periphery, the continuous distribution of ventilation to perfusion (VA/Q) gives a particularly important information while diagnosing the functional abnormalities in patients with a variety of lung diseases [1,2]. The heterogeneity of VA/Q distribution is the key mechanism that gives rise to hypoxemia and/ or hypercapnia in patients with a variety of lung diseases. It is worth noting that pulmonary physiology, which stresses the heterogeneity of functional properties leading to impaired overall function, is well ahead of other areas of physiology. In other organs, the heterogeneous distribution of functional properties in an organ is well known but little interest has been directed toward the consequences of such functional heterogeneity. As such, the developmental process of pulmonary physiology is unique in comparison with that of other organs [2]. However, there remains the serious problem in pulmonary gas exchange physiology represented by VA/Q heterogeneity; that is, the endeavors to ensure the relationship between functional heterogeneity and structural lesion do not end successfully [1]. Although the great efforts of elucidating the direct communication (i.e., the establishment of one-to-one relationship) between structural and functional abnormalities in the lung periphery have been made in the era of the 20th century, particularly from the 1950’s to the 1980’s, it is hard to say that the efforts to unite them in a variety of directions are successfully enough. Furthermore, it is of clinical necessity to have a profound knowledge about the issue of what structural abnormality is detected from the functional VA/Q heterogeneity while physicians should do a pathophysiological decision-making against a patient with a certain lung disease. In view of these historical facts and clinical requirements, the present review highlights the issue of specifying the structural (anatomical) backgrounds underlying the functional parameter of continuous distribution of VA/Q that has been used for estimating gas exchange dynamics in the lung periphery. For accomplishing this purpose, the three matters were comprehensively addressed. (1) What is the most appropriate organization serving as the functional gas exchange unit, which is certainly backed by the structural design of the lung periphery? (2) Is the VA/Q distribution, which is quantified by means of the Multiple Inert Gas Elimination Technique (MIGET), indeed supported by the structural (anatomical) facts? (3) Based on the measurements of continuous distribution of VA/Q in patients with pathologically- and/or radiologically-confirmed lung diseases, the attempt was made to certify the structure-function relationships in the lungs with various kinds of specific diseases in a precise fashion.

What is the Most Appropriate Organization Serving as Functional Gas Exchange Unit?

Anatomical design for estimating gas transport in conductive airways: From the anatomical standpoint, the lung is divided into two parts. The region with conductive airways (central and peripheral airways) with a dichotomous branching geometry having no alveoli configures the anatomical dead space, through which environmental air is transported to the lung periphery. On the other hand, the region having a tremendous number of alveoli engaging in gas exchange is defined as the acinus. The morphometric data of airway trees can be abstracted into two types of models that extend from the trachea to the terminal alveolar sacs [3-5]. Model A stresses the basic properties of airway branching by assuming the regular dichotomy and thus defining a symmetric typical-path model, while model B defines the irregularities of tree architecture with asymmetric branching and defines the properties of a variable path model.

In the symmetrical typical-path model of A (equivalent to the model A of Weibel [1,5]), the airway branches in a certain generation are assumed to have the same diameter and length. Thus, the diameterto- length ratio is also treated to be similar in all generations. The total cross-sectional area of all airways in each generation increases tremendously toward the airways located in the periphery. For this feature, the typical-path model of A has been called “trumpet” or “thumbtack” model, as well [6]. In this case, it is necessary to note that the essential factor that defines the airway dimension is the number of generations. The detailed criticisms on the typical-path model of A was found elsewhere [1,5]. Briefly, (1) this model assumes that all anatomical gas exchange units (i.e., acini) are found at an equal distance from the trachea. This is a gross simplification if we gaze the anatomical fact that some terminations of conductive airways end after a shorter distance than others. (2) While the diameter shows a relatively symmetric distribution in airways belonging to the same generation, the segment length is highly skewed. (3) The diameter of acinar airways precisely examined by Haefeli-Bleuer and Weibel [7] is not predicted from the regression line constructed for estimating the diameter of conductive airways.

The starting point for defining the asymmetrical model of B is based on the anatomical finding that airways with a certain diameter occur in several generations and at different distances from the origin of airways [5]. For instance, airways of 2 mm diameter are found in generations 4 to 14, with a maximum in generation 8. Alternatively, these bronchi are located at 18 to 31 cm from the origin of trachea with a maximum at 24 cm. Note that in the symmetrical typicalpath model of A, bronchi with 2 mm diameter are located maximally in generation 8 corresponding to 23.6 cm from the trachea, which is in a close agreement with the distance that shows the maximum distribution of bronchi having 2 mm diameter in the variable path model of B [5]. Based on these facts, one may conceive that although the symmetrical typical-path model of A has various limitations, it works approximately as an acceptable model for predicting airway branching, at least in lower conductive airways from trachea to terminal bronchioles. When attempting to precisely evaluate the convection-related gas transport dynamics in conductive airways toward terminal bronchioles, a more realistic model such as variable path model of B with an asymmetrical branching architecture should be applied. However, when considering the gas mixing dynamics in the acinar region, the difference in models for conductive airways may exert little impact. This is because the relative contribution of diffusion is equivalent to, or predominates, that of convective flow in the acinar region [6].

Anatomical design for estimating gas exchange in lung periphery: The alveolus cannot be taken as a ventilation unit mostly because each alveolus is not independent of other alveoli. Two adjoining alveoli share the alveolar wall and each alveolus adjoins several alveoli, some of which are connected to different alveolar ducts. Furthermore, there are communications at the level of respiratory bronchioles or alveolar ducts defined as Martin channels [8]. In addition, there is a serious problem concerning a perfusion unit formed by the pulmonary microcirculation. The dense, intertwined capillary network embedded in the alveolar wall forms a continuum of blood flow that is not partitioned into independent perfusion units, resulting in that the story one likes to present, i.e., the anatomical gas exchange unit is organized into an alveolus associated with a separated capillary network in the alveolar wall, is highly fictitious. The capillary network is supplied by the arteriole penetrating the acinus along acinar airways and is drained into the venule in the acinar periphery. The distance between an arteriole and a venule is of an order between 0.5 and 1.0 mm [9], resulting in that the perfusion unit given by the area surrounded by an arteriole and a venule extends over several alveoli. These facts are in accord with the idea that the perfusion unit is not congruent with the ventilation unit if it is composed of an alveolus, giving rise to difficulty in anatomically defining the gas exchange unit from an alveolus and a capillary network, in which the ventilation and perfusion units should be matched.

The traditional rationale for anatomical ventilation unit was evolved based on the concept of acinus, the ventilation into which is supplied by a terminal bronchiole (corresponding to the 14th generation in typical-path model of A) that is the last peripheral airway without alveoli. This type of ventilation unit is generally called the acinus of Loeschcke (Figure 1). There are many other terms that define the region equivalent to the acinus of Loeschcke [10-16]. The size of acinus of Loeschcke averages 7 to 10 mm in diameter and roughly 30,000 acini configure the lung. An acinus contains alveoli ranging from 3,000 to 4,000 [7], resulting in that the lung consists of about a hundred million alveoli.