Cytological Examination versus Traditional Biopsy in Detection of Right Diaphragmatic Copula Affection in Advanced Ovarian Cancer

Research Article

Austin J Obstet Gynecol. 2020; 7(1): 1152.

Cytological Examination versus Traditional Biopsy in Detection of Right Diaphragmatic Copula Affection in Advanced Ovarian Cancer

Essmat AAAM1*, Meleis M1, Agamia A2, Amin B2 and Abdallah D2

¹Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Faculty of Medicine, Alexandria University, Egypt

²Department of pathology, Faculty of Medicine, Alexandria University, Egypt

*Corresponding author: Ahmad Abdel Azeem Mohammad Essmat, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, El-shatby Maternity University Hospital, Faculty of Medicine, Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt

Received: January 27, 2020; Accepted: February 25, 2020; Published: March 03, 2020

Abstract

Introduction: With involvement of the upper abdomen, metastasis to diaphragm, especially to the right hemi-diaphragm, are very common and up 40% of patients advanced-stage ovarian cancer have bulky metastatic diaphragmatic disease which leads to suboptimal cytoreduction and therefore to a lower rate of survival. The best technique for obtaining cytological specimens necessary for evaluation of diaphragmatic spread among women undergoing surgical staging for ovarian cancer has yet to be determined. Although diaphragmatic wash specimens provide better-quality smears than scrape specimens, both techniques are equally diagnostic of diaphragmatic involvement in women undergoing surgical staging for ovarian cancer.

Aim: To evaluate the accuracy of cytological scraping of the diaphragm in relation to the standard traditional biopsy in detection of right diaphragmatic copula affection in cases of advanced ovarian cancer.

Methods: Type of the study was prospective cohort study and Was conducted in El Shatby University Maternity Hospital on 40 patients with advanced ovarian malignancy stage III, IV and No history of radiation neither chemo therapy. They underwent surgical staging for ovarian cancer, the surgical approach is by laparotomy. In each patient, Two samples will be obtained, The first sample (sample 1) Rt. Diaphragmatic copula scrap specimen was obtained using a sterile Ayers spatula then the undersurface of the diaphragm was inspected and palpated . The specimen was fixed by 95% alcohol on a sterile microscopic glass slide and was sent to be examined by the pathologist using papanicolaou stain for the presence or absence of malignant cells. The second sample (sample 2) the right copula of diaphragm was surgically biopsied using a conventional knife, then specimen was fixed immediately on a glass slide using formalin then stained by H&E stain to be examined for presence or absence of malignant cells.

Results: Comparison between the two groups showed that the mean of RMI in biopsy negative patients was 462.62±400.43u/l lower than the mean in biopsy positive patients 4593.43±4830u/l which showed a statistical significance (p-value=0.000). Comparison between the two groups showed that the mean of RMI in Scratch negative patients was 1528.81±3238 u/l lower than the mean in Scratch positive patients 3426±4044u/l which showed non statistical significance (p-value=0.166)

Conclusions: In the ovarian cancer diaphragm is the third most affected organ of occult diseases just after the peritoneum and the colon. Cytological diaphragmatic smears were suggested to be done as a supplemental tool; however, they not routinely taken and their usefulness is still unclear. Cytological diaphragmatic smears by scratch can provide a great additional benefit in the detection of the peritoneal disease within these patients. There was fair agreement between biopsy outcomes with statically significantly related to scratch outcomes with 42.95 % sensitivity; 92.33 % specificity and 75% accuracy within these patients with ovarian cancer patients. Scrapping is less sensitive than biopsy in case of right compilation peritoneum dissection

Keywords: Ovarian Cancer; Scraping; Biopsy; Diaphragm

Introduction

Epithelial ovarian cancer is the second most common genital malignancy in women and it is the most lethal gynecological malignancy, with an estimated five-year survival rate of 39% [1]. Despite efforts to develop an effective ovarian cancer screening method, 60% of patients still, present with advanced (Stages III-IV) disease. CA-125 serum levels, transvaginal ultrasound, and pelvic examination have long been thought to be potentially effective screening tools. However, none of them have proved effective in decreasing mortality from ovarian cancer [2]. An epithelial ovarian tumor arises from the serosal lining of the ovary, which communicates with the serosal lining of the abdomino-pelvic cavity known as the peritoneum. As a consequence of tumor growth, malignant cells exfoliate and shed, becoming free floating in the peritoneal fluid [3].

They typically implant in the pelvis and sub-diaphragmatic recesses owing to gravity and the recumbent position. This spread of the tumor within the peritoneum is termed peritoneal carcinomatosis, and it is a typical feature of cancer spread in patients with primary advanced or recurrent epithelial ovarian cancers [4]. Intraoperatively, it is characterized by the presence of macroscopic tumor nodules of variable sizes and consistencies that can coalesce to form plaques or masses within the abdominopelvic cavity [5]. Tumor dissemination from the peritoneal cavity into the pleural cavity might also occur through the lymphatic lacunae within the diaphragmatic peritoneum. This results in severe pleural effusion, which compromises lung and cardiac function. It typically presents with vague gastrointestinal symptoms, such as abdominal bloating, distension, weight loss, and fatigue. Due to the heterogeneity and lack of specificity of these early clinical symptoms, diagnosis is often delayed [6].

With involvement of the upper abdomen, metastasis to diaphragm, especially to the right hemi-diaphragm, are very common and up 40% of patients advanced-stage ovarian cancer have bulky metastatic diaphragmatic disease which leads to suboptimal cytoreduction and therefore to a lower rate of survival [6]. The best technique for obtaining cytological specimens necessary for evaluation of diaphragmatic spread among women undergoing surgical staging for ovarian cancer has yet to be determined [10]. Although diaphragmatic wash specimens provide better-quality smears than scrape specimens, both techniques are equally diagnostic of diaphragmatic involvement in women undergoing surgical staging for ovarian cancer [7].

The AIM OF THE WORK was to evaluate the accuracy of cytological scraping of the diaphragm in relation to the standard traditional biopsy in detection of right diaphragmatic copula affection in cases of advanced ovarian cancer.

Methods

Type of the study was prospective cohort study and Was conducted in El Shatby University Maternity Hospital on 40 patients with advanced ovarian malignancy stage III, IV and No history of radiation neither chemo therapy. They underwent surgical staging for ovarian cancer, the surgical approach is by laparotomy. In each patient ,Two samples will be obtained, The first sample (sample 1) Rt. Diaphragmatic copula scrap specimen was obtained using a sterile Ayers spatula then the undersurface of the diaphragm was inspected and palpated . The specimen was fixed by 95% alcohol on a sterile microscopic glass slide and was sent to be examined by the pathologist using papanicolaou stain for the presence or absence of malignant cells. The second sample (sample 2) the right copula of diaphragm was surgically biopsied using a conventional knife, then specimen was fixed immediately on a glass slide using formalin then stained by H&E stain to be examined for presence or absence of malignant cells. After performance of pathological examination of two specimens, sample (1) i.e. cytology, was compared to sample (2) i.e. conventional biopsy which was regarded as the gold standard.

Results

The patients mean of age was 48.75±12.766 years and of the BMI was 29.05±4.624 kg/m2. the patients` mean of CA125 was 388.7±756.9466u/l and of the RMI was 1908±3444.363u/l. 6 (15%) patients had DM, 2 (5%) had DM & HTN, 2 (5) had DM & HTN and were cardiac, 2 (5%) with hyperthyroid, 2 (5%) with hypothyroid, 2 (5%) with ischemic heart disease and 20 (50%) were free. The patients were distributed according to their menopausal state into perimenopausal 8 (20%), 20 (50%) postmenopausal and 12 (30%) premenopausal. Patients were distributed according to their Gravidity Parity where the G0P0 included 8 (20%) patients, and G2P2, G3P3, G4P3+1 each included 4 (10%) andG1P1, G5P4+1, G6P4+2, G6P5+1, G7P6+1, G8P6+2, G8P8 each included 2 (5%) and finally G4P4 included 6 (15%) patients. Patients that had HCV were 4 (10%), HBV were 2 (5%), HBV & HCV were 2 (5%) and 32 (80%) patients were HBV &HCV negative. patients were distributed according to Radiology stage into 36 (90%) in stage three and 4 (10%) in stage four. patients were distributed according to biopsy outcomes into 26 (65%) negative and 14 (35%) positive. Patients were distributed according to scratch outcomes into 32 (80%) negative and 8 (20%) positive. Comparison between the two groups showed that mean of CA125 in biopsy negative patients was 67.68±45.32u/l lower than the mean in biopsy positive patients 842±1138u/l which showed a statistical significance (p-value=0.001). Comparison between the two groups showed that the mean of CA125 in Scratch negative patients was 186.8±354.31u/l lower than the mean in Scratch positive patients 946.25±1452.32u/l which showed a statistical significance (p-value=0.009) (Table 1,2).

Citation: Essmat AAAM, Meleis M, Agamia A, Amin B and Abdallah D. Cytological Examination versus Traditional Biopsy in Detection of Right Diaphragmatic Copula Affection in Advanced Ovarian Cancer. Austin J Obstet Gynecol. 2020; 7(1): 1152.